Journal · Craft
The Time That's Missing
In the article on eclecticism I described how Milan, in design, has always made the same gesture: taking languages from elsewhere and putting them back in order with a measure of its own.
In fashion, in the same years, the city did the same. It looked to Paris, to the Renaissance, to industry, to pop. And it translated them. I'm setting the two stories side by side, because they mirror each other more than it seems.
The nineteenth century: Paris as model, Milan as market
While architecture was building the Galleria, Milanese fashion was looking to Paris. In 1865 the Bocconi brothers opened, on Via Santa Radegonda, what is considered Italy's first shop selling ready-made clothes. In 1877 they launched Aux Villes d'Italie, the country's first department store, modelled on the Bon Marché in Paris.
What it meets: the French model, ready-to-wear, the department store.
What it moves away from: made-to-measure tailoring as the only way to a garment.
As with eclecticism, it starts from a foreign language. But it turns it into a civic institution.
The twentieth century: the first Italian fashion
At the 1906 Milan Exposition, the dressmaker Rosa Genoni won the international jury's Grand Prix. She wanted an Italian fashion that didn't copy Paris, and to build it she looked to the early Renaissance: Botticelli, Pisanello, the Tanagra figurines.
In 1917 Senator Borletti took over the Bocconi stores and asked Gabriele D'Annunzio for a new name. He chose Rinascente: rebirth.
What it meets: the Renaissance, antiquity, a first national pride.
What it moves away from: copying.
It's the same gesture as Muzio's Ca' Brutta. The classical put back in order, to say something new.
The 1930s: the constraint
In 1935 the League of Nations imposed sanctions on Italy over the invasion of Ethiopia. The regime responded with autarky. That same year the National Fashion Board was founded in Turin, and posters urged people to dress the Italian way. An identity decided by decree.
The constraint produced two opposite stories.
The first is Lanital, a fibre made from milk casein, whose patent SNIA Viscosa acquired in 1935. Marinetti dedicated a poem to it. But the fabric was weaker than wool, barely elastic, and when damp it smelled of sour milk. Propaganda promised; the material contradicted it.
The second is a shoe. Sanctions made it hard to find the German steel used for shanks, the metal core that supports the sole of the foot. Salvatore Ferragamo replaced it with cork, and in 1937 he patented the wedge. He made it remarkably comfortable, because it holds and supports the arch of the foot.
Personally, I don't love wedges. But I understand their purpose, and for anyone who has designed shoes for many years the lesson doesn't age: in the hands of craft, a constraint becomes a language.
What it meets: autarky, new materials, national tailoring.
What it moves away from: Paris, but by obligation.
Design in those same years, with Ponti, was seeking a free, domestic modernity. Fashion was subjected to an imposed identity. Yet even within that obligation, those with craft found their own way.
The post-war years: Florence shows, Milan produces
On 12 February 1951, Giovanni Battista Giorgini presented the first Italian high-fashion show in Florence, at his Villa Torrigiani. From 1952 the shows moved to the Sala Bianca of Palazzo Pitti. Italian fashion was born in Florence.
Milan, meanwhile, had industry: textiles, manufacturing, distribution. And in 1954 Rinascente created the Compasso d'Oro, the award that would become the highest honour in Italian industrial design. Fashion and design met under the same roof.
What it meets: Florentine high fashion, the American market, industry.
What it moves away from: the idea that fashion is only couture.
This is the culture of design: a beautiful object must also be conceived to be produced.
The 1970s and 1980s: the designer
In 1971 Walter Albini left Florence and presented his first collection under his own name in Milan. Within a few years many followed. Milanese ready-to-wear was born: the fashion designer works for industry, as the product designer works for production.
In 1975 Giorgio Armani founded his label, bringing Milanese measure into clothing. In the 1980s, the years of Memphis, Franco Moschino turned irony against the fashion system itself.
What it meets: industry, the global market, irony.
What it moves away from: haute couture, and with Moschino even from fashion's own seriousness.
Armani is measure. Moschino is the Memphis of fashion.
Today: the time that's missing
Today fashion has folded in on itself, under the hegemony of finance. Fashion designers and designers have less and less room to express themselves.
Finance is willing to pay for everything, except the one thing that would truly matter: time.
In the 1930s materials were scarce, but there was time to invent. Ferragamo could replace steel with cork because he had the time to try, fail, and try again. Today there is everything, except time. And without time, no translation is possible: all that remains is the quick copy of what has already worked.
A dream
I wait, hopefully, for new codes and new levers to emerge, free from these dynamics. A utopian dream, but I like to dream.
Three questions to ask yourself
Am I enduring the constraint in front of me, or turning it into a language?
Am I translating a model, or copying it?
In my project, how much time have I left for error?
If an answer hesitates, there's a lens to clean. Let's talk.
This is the work I do. It's called coherence.